Catholic vs. Public

I’m looking for the brutal truth about Catholic vs. Public schools in hamilton, specifically elementary because my daughter will be starting school this September! I keep going back and forth, pros and cons of both, and I’m so torn 😩 we’re not religious per say although my husband and I both attended Catholic growing up. She isn’t baptized but it is something we considered. Help please, any advice is helpful!! We live in east hamilton

Thank you!